Learning Center

writing

Advance students from opinion to persuasive to argumentative

october 16, 2023

Compare Argumentative v Persuasive Writing

Opinion versus Persuasive versus Argumentative WritingAll grade levels have a writing standard that outlines teaching argument. This standard progresses from an opinion with reasons in K-2 to a one-sided persuasive with reasons and evidence in grades 3-5 to a sophisticated argumentative that juggles multiple perspectives, sharing strengths and limitations of all. This is the expectation in grades 6-12.

Each of these builds on one another, providing a K-12 scaffold. In order to develop an argument, one must first be able to state an opinion and write persuasively. Plan several opportunities throughout the year for students to experience this mode of writing.

Scale Image for Opinion Writing

OPINION doesn’t even realize that there are other positions.

Scale Image for Persuasive Writing

PERSUASIVE is all one-sided, supporting a single position.

Scale image for Argumentative Writing

ARGUMENTATIVE reveals multiple perspectives but aligns with one.

When starting a unit in any of these genres, begin first by outlining the subtle, but significant differences among them. Download a chart that defines each and their purposes, techniques, components, etc. It’s helpful to compare what students already know about opinion and persuasive writing as you introduce them to the new and less familiar concepts of argumentative writing.

For more information on the skills and expectations at all levels, check out the dissection of the K-12 college and career-ready standards.

Argumentative Writing Standards Dissected - Grades K-12
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
CompCON 2024
Compare argumentative versus persuasive writing

[writing]

Compare argumentative vs. persuasive writing

Answer the Great Pronoun Debate

[writing]

Answer the great pronoun debate

Evaluate 4 factors in argument analysis

[writing]

Evaluate 4 factors in argument analysis